It’s an established fact in Jewish tradition that Torah scrolls, tefillin and mezuzot must be written on parchment (animal hide), and that the parchment must be from a kosher animal. Oddly enough, however, the animal need not have been slaughtered in accordance with halachah (Jewish law).
The fact that the parchment must be from a kosher species is a tradition cited as dating back to Moses at Mount Sinai.1 A hint to this is also seen in the Torah, where, in reference to tefillin, the verse states, “... so that G‑d’s Torah will be in your mouth.”2 Read literally, it can mean that only the hide of an animal that is permitted to be placed “in your mouth,” meaning an animal that is permitted to be eaten, may be used.3
The Talmud itself raises an obvious question: Why then does the animal not need to have been properly slaughtered?
Indeed, this question was presented to Rabbi Yehoshua HaGarsi by a Boethusian, a member of a Second-Temple era sect that rejected the Rabbinic tradition.
Rabbi Yehoshua replied with a parable:
“I will tell you a parable. To what is this similar? To two people who were sentenced to death by the king. One was killed by the king himself, and the other was killed by an executioner. Which one is more praiseworthy? You must say: The one whom the king himself killed. Therefore, an animal that died at the hands of Heaven, rather than through human action, is superior.”
The Boethusian responded:
“If so, then such animals should be allowed to be eaten, as they were killed by the king!”
Rabbi Yehoshua replied:
“The Torah says, ‘Do not eat any carrion,’4 and you say they should be eaten?”
In other words, the Torah explicitly prohibits eating these animals, but that does not mean their hides are inferior or disqualified for use. The Boethusian conceded: “Well put.”
The commentators raise a further question: If the requirement is simply that the material come from something that may be eaten, why not use gold, since it is technically permitted to be eaten?5 And what about paper made from plant fibers, which are also technically permissible to eat?6
They explain that the verse requires not merely something that is technically permissible to eat, but something that is actually food. Gold, which is not food, is therefore disqualified. Similarly, the material cannot come from a plant, since the category of a forbidden species being “in your mouth” must at least be applicable. With plants, however, this category is not relevant. Although certain plants are prohibited because of orlah or kilayim, these are prohibitions that apply to the particular circumstances or status of the plant, rather than to the species itself.7
Thus, as we have explained, the requirement that a Torah scroll be written on parchment is either a tradition dating back to Sinai or is derived from a verse in the Torah, and as such would be classified as a “gezeirat hakatuv,” a decree.
Despite this, the mystics offer possible explanations for this requirement.
The Mystical Significance of Animal Parchment
The Mystics explain that when a physical object is used to perform a mitzvah, it obtains a status of holiness. The Alter Rebbe in Tanya specifically cites the parchment of Torah scrolls, tefillin, and mezuzahs as examples. Kosher animals derive their vitality from “kelipat nogah,” a spiritual realm containing both good and evil, which can be refined and elevated through mitzvot. Forbidden animals, by contrast, derive from the three completely impure kelipot, which cannot be elevated. Thus, the parchment must come from a kosher species, whose hide has the potential to be transformed into a vessel for holiness.8
The Rebbe adds that when it comes to animal hides, this elevation encompasses all of creation. The Mystics divide the world into four categories: inanimate, vegetation, animal, and humankind. In preparing parchment, water (inanimate) and herbs (vegetation) are used to process the animal hide (animal). When a person (humankind) uses that parchment to fulfill a mitzvah, all four categories are brought together and elevated, demonstrating that G‑d is the Master and Creator of all existence.9
This also explains why the hide need not come from an animal that was properly slaughtered. The species itself is kosher and therefore retains its potential for elevation, even if the particular animal is prohibited to eat.
Chassidic masters explain that the permission to use such hides teaches that even something that has fallen into a compromised state, as long as it stems from or retains some Divine connection, can be rectified and elevated.10
Uplifting the Skin of Imagination
Another explanation some chassidic masters give is that animal hide represents the “koach hamedameh” (the imaginative faculty), which is the external garment of the intellect. This faculty mediates between the physical and spiritual worlds, but it can also become distorted and lead to mistaken perceptions and desires. By writing sacred texts on animal hide, the holiness of Torah penetrates and refines this faculty, elevating it toward holiness. Thus, the use of animal parchment symbolizes the Torah's ability to refine not only our intellect, but even the more external and lower faculties of the mind.11